4 Spooky Ghost Pizza Bagels Kids Will Adore This Halloween

Let me tell you about my favorite Halloween party trick – Ghost Pizza Bagels! These adorable little spooky snacks have saved every one of my October gatherings since I first tried making them for my nephew’s monster bash. The concept couldn’t be simpler: take regular pizza bagels and transform them into a hauntingly good appetizer with just some clever olive placement. What I love most is how even the pickiest little goblins go crazy for them – they’re cheesy, saucy, and just scary enough to be exciting without being actually frightening. Last year, I made three batches and they disappeared faster than a ghost in the night!

The magic of these Ghost Pizza Bagels lies in their perfect balance between festive and familiar. Kids recognize the pizza flavors they adore, while the cute ghost faces make them feel special for Halloween. I’ve watched grown adults giggle while arranging the olive eyes just right – it’s that kind of recipe that brings out everyone’s playful side. And when the melted mozzarella forms wispy “tails” around the edges during baking? Pure magic. Trust me, once you try these, they’ll become your new must-make Halloween tradition too.

Ingredients for Ghost Pizza Bagels

Here’s what you’ll need to bring these adorable little ghosts to life in your kitchen. I’ve made these so many times I could probably recite the ingredient list in my sleep – but I still double check everything before starting because nobody wants a ghost without eyes mid-recipe!

• 4 plain bagels – sliced horizontally (go for fresh ones – they toast up so much better)
• 1 cup pizza sauce – your favorite brand or homemade
• 2 cups shredded mozzarella cheese – the stringier the better for those wispy ghost tails!
• 1/2 cup sliced black olives – these will be our ghostly eyes (I like to cut some in half for different expressions)
• 1/4 cup mini pepperoni slices (optional) – perfect for making little ghost mouths if you want extra personality
• 1 tsp dried oregano – for that authentic pizza parlor aroma
• 1 tsp garlic powder – because everything’s better with garlic

See? Nothing too scary in this ingredients list! The beauty of this recipe is that you probably have most of these things in your kitchen already. I sometimes add a pinch of red pepper flakes when I’m making these for adults – gives the ghosts a little spicy attitude!

Equipment Needed for Ghost Pizza Bagels

One of the best things about making Ghost Pizza Bagels? You don’t need any fancy kitchen gadgets! I’ve whipped these up in tiny apartment kitchens and at friends’ houses – as long as you’ve got these basic tools, you’re golden.

• Baking sheet – Any standard size will do, but I prefer rimmed ones to catch any rogue cheese
• Sharp knife – For slicing those bagels perfectly in half (safety first – ghost fingers aren’t part of this recipe!)
• Oven – Set to our magic number: 375°F
• Spoon or spatula – For spreading that saucy goodness evenly
• Cutting board – To prep your olive eyes and pepperoni smiles

That’s seriously it! No special ghost-making tools required. Though I will confess – I did buy a little Halloween-themed baking sheet last year just for these. Not necessary, but it does make me smile when those cheesy ghosts come out of the oven looking extra festive.

How to Make Ghost Pizza Bagels

Ready to bring these adorable ghosties to life? Let me walk you through my foolproof method – it’s so easy you’ll be making them in your sleep (maybe that’s why they’re ghosts?). The key is taking your time with each step to create perfect little pizza specters that’ll haunt your taste buds in the best way possible.

Preparing the Bagels

First things first – let’s get those bagels prepped! I like to lay all my bagel halves out on the baking sheet before adding anything. This “ghost assembly line” method keeps me organized. Spread about 1-2 tablespoons of pizza sauce on each half – don’t skimp, but don’t drown them either. You want enough sauce to peek through the cheese later.

Now comes the cheesy magic! Sprinkle shredded mozzarella generously over each sauced bagel half. I aim for full coverage but leave just a tiny border around the edges – this helps create those wispy ghost tails when the cheese melts and bubbles up in the oven. Pro tip: mix a little grated parmesan in with your mozzarella for extra flavor depth.

Creating the Ghost Faces

This is where the fun begins! Using your sliced black olives, place two pieces on each bagel half to make ghost eyes. I like to vary their positions – some ghosts look straight ahead, others glance sideways for a playful group. For extra personality, add a tiny half-circle of pepperoni underneath the eyes to make a little “O” shaped ghost mouth.

Get creative here! I’ve made ghosts with surprised expressions (big round eyes), sleepy ghosts (half-moon shaped olive pieces), even ghosts sticking their tongues out (use a thin slice of pepperoni). Kids love helping with this part – just be prepared for some hilarious ghost face designs!

Baking and Serving

Pop your ghostly creations into the preheated 375°F oven and set a timer for 12 minutes. What you’re looking for is melted, bubbly cheese with those edges just starting to turn golden. About halfway through, I like to rotate the pan for even browning – ghosts shouldn’t have tan lines!

For extra crispiness, turn on the broiler for the last 1-2 minutes, but WATCH CLOSELY – ghosts can go from perfectly golden to spookily burnt in seconds! Serve warm when the cheese is at its stringiest, melty best. These taste amazing fresh from the oven but honestly? They’re almost as good at room temperature when you’re busy hosting.

Tips for Perfect Ghost Pizza Bagels

After making these Halloween treats more times than I can count, I’ve picked up some tricks (and treats!) to make sure your Ghost Pizza Bagels come out scarily good every time. Here are my best tips that even beginner ghost-makers will appreciate!

• Fresh bagels make all the difference – Stale bagels turn cardboard-y when baked. I grab mine from the bakery section the same day I’m making these. If you must use day-old bagels, give them a quick spritz of water before adding toppings – it helps bring back some moisture.
• Broiler vigilance is key – That final broil gives the ghosts their perfect golden glow, but walk away for even 30 seconds and you might return to charred spirits! I literally stand by the oven door counting “one-Mississippi” while broiling.
• Experiment with veggie toppings – For Halloween parties with vegetarians, skip the pepperoni and try sliced mushrooms or bell peppers. I once made “veggie ghost” versions with tiny broccoli florets as hair – the kids went nuts for them!
• Prep your olives in advance – On party days, I slice all my black olives first thing in the morning and keep them in a little bowl. When it’s ghost-making time, everything moves faster and I can focus on giving each one personality.

Remember – ghosts aren’t perfect, and neither do these pizza bagels need to be! Some of my favorite batches have lopsided eyes or extra-cheesy “tails” where the mozzarella bubbled over. That’s part of their spooky charm.

Ghost Pizza Bagels Variations

One of my favorite things about this recipe is how easily it adapts to different diets and tastes. Over the years, I’ve had to get creative for friends with food restrictions – turns out ghosts can be dairy-free or gluten-free too! Here are my top three tested-and-approved variations that still deliver all the fun of the original.

Spooky Vegan Ghosts

For my plant-based pals, simply swap in your favorite vegan mozzarella (the shreds that melt best, in my experience) and skip the pepperoni. The black olive eyes still work perfectly! I like to add a sprinkle of nutritional yeast over the top before baking for extra umami flavor. Last Halloween, I even made a cashew-based “cream cheese ghost” version that was downright eerie how close it tasted to the real thing.

Gluten-Free Phantom Bagels

No need for gluten-sensitive guests to miss out! Use your preferred gluten-free bagels – the smaller, denser ones actually hold up better than you’d think. Just toast them lightly before adding toppings to prevent sogginess. Pro tip: Gluten-free bagels brown faster, so check them at 10 minutes and tent with foil if needed. I’ve had great results with the “everything” GF bagels – the seeds add nice texture!

Breakfast Ghosts

Why should dinner have all the fun? For Halloween brunch, I make a breakfast version with scrambled egg “sauce,” cheddar cheese ghosts, and bacon bit smiles. My niece calls them “ghost toasts” and requests them every October. You can even do sweet ghosts with cream cheese “sauce,” white chocolate chips for eyes, and a strawberry jam mouth – though I’ll admit those disappear faster than you can say “Boo!”

The possibilities are endless once you start playing with the concept. I’ve seen witches make mummy versions with cheese strips, Frankenstein bagels with veggie toppings – let your imagination run wild! After all, isn’t that what Halloween cooking is all about?

Storing and Reheating Ghost Pizza Bagels

Now, let me share my ghostly secrets for keeping these pizza bagels tasting fresh – because let’s face it, sometimes you need to make them ahead or deal with leftovers (though I’ve never seen many leftovers when I serve these!). The good news? With the right storage tricks, your Ghost Pizza Bagels will haunt your fridge almost as well as they haunt your taste buds!

Storage Tips: First, let those little ghosts cool completely – trapping steam leads to soggy bagel spirits. Then pop them in an airtight container with parchment between layers. They’ll keep for 2-3 days in the fridge, though the olives might get a bit softer. Freezing? Possible, but the texture changes enough that I usually don’t bother – these are so quick to make fresh!

Reheating Magic: The oven is absolutely the way to go for reviving these ghosts to their former glory. Preheat to 350°F and bake for 8-10 minutes until the cheese gets melty again. No oven? A toaster oven works great too! Microwave works in a pinch (20-30 seconds), but expect softer texture – I call these “sleepy ghosts.” Pro tip: If the olive eyes fell off during storage, just pop fresh ones on after reheating – instant ghost makeover!

One Halloween, I actually made an extra batch just to test storage methods (yes, I’m that obsessed). The oven-reheated ones were nearly identical to fresh, while microwaved versions lost some crispness but kept all the flavor. So don’t stress if you need to make these ahead – your ghostly guests will still be delicious!

Nutritional Information for Ghost Pizza Bagels

Let’s talk numbers – but don’t worry, nothing scary here! While these Ghost Pizza Bagels might look like they’re all fun and games, they actually pack some decent nutrition behind those cheesy smiles. Keep in mind these are estimates based on standard ingredients – your exact numbers might ghost around a bit depending on brands and toppings.

Per serving (1 pizza bagel half):

• Calories: 220
• Protein: 10g (not bad for a little ghost!)
• Carbohydrates: 28g
• Fiber: 2g
• Sugar: 3g
• Fat: 8g
• Saturated Fat: 4g
• Sodium: 480mg

Now, I’m no nutritionist, but here’s what I’ve noticed – these make a pretty balanced snack! You’ve got protein from the cheese, carbs from the bagel, and those black olive eyes actually add some healthy fats. The sodium might seem high, but remember Halloween is a special occasion – ghosts don’t come knocking every day! For lighter versions, try low-sodium cheese or sauce, or load up on veggie toppings to balance it out.

Pro tip from my kitchen experiments: Adding pepperoni increases calories by about 15 per bagel half, while swapping in part-skim mozzarella can save you around 20 calories. But honestly? For these once-a-year treats, I say let the ghosts be their delicious, cheesy selves!

FAQs About Ghost Pizza Bagels

Over the years, I’ve gotten every question imaginable about these spooky snacks – from panicked parents at midnight Halloween prep to curious neighbors peeking over my kitchen counter. Here are the answers to the questions I hear most often, straight from my ghost-making experience!

Can I make Ghost Pizza Bagels ahead of time?

Absolutely! These little ghosts are surprisingly cooperative when it comes to advance prep. You can assemble them completely (sauce, cheese, and all) up to 4 hours before baking – just cover tightly with plastic wrap and refrigerate. Add 1-2 minutes to the baking time since you’re starting with cold ingredients. I sometimes even freeze unbaked assembled bagels for up to a month – perfect for last-minute Halloween emergencies!

Can I use English muffins instead of bagels?

You bet! English muffins make adorable mini ghosts – just watch the baking time since they’re thinner. I reduce it to about 8-10 minutes. The nooks and crannies hold sauce beautifully too! My kids call these “baby ghosts” and they’re perfect for little hands. Pro tip: Toast the English muffins lightly before adding toppings to prevent sogginess.

How do I keep the bagels from getting soggy?

Ah, the dreaded ghost mush – we’ve all been there! Here’s my foolproof method: First, don’t oversauce – stick to that 1-2 tbsp per half. Second, use fresh bagels (day-olds tend to absorb more moisture). Third – and this is key – bake at 375°F, not lower. The higher heat helps evaporate moisture quickly for crispier results. If all else fails, a quick minute under the broiler at the end can rescue even the soggiest ghost!

Bonus tip I learned the hard way: Let baked Ghost Pizza Bagels rest for 2-3 minutes before serving – this lets the cheese set slightly so toppings stay put when you bite in. Nothing scarier than a ghost losing its face mid-bite!

Why You’ll Love Ghost Pizza Bagels

Let me count the ways these adorable little spooky snacks will steal your heart (and probably become your new Halloween tradition)! After making these for years, I’ve discovered so many reasons why Ghost Pizza Bagels deserve a spot in your recipe rotation – here are the big ones that keep me coming back every October.

• Lightning-fast fun – From fridge to table in under 30 minutes means you can whip up a ghost army even when you’re scrambling with last-minute party prep. I’ve literally made these while wearing a witch costume and dodging trick-or-treaters at my door!
• Endlessly customizable – Whether you’re feeding picky kids, vegan friends, or gluten-free guests, these ghosts adapt beautifully. I love how one basic concept can morph into a dozen variations – my recipe notebook is full of spooky experiments!
• Kid-approved magic – There’s something about shaping food into characters that makes kids actually want to eat it. I’ve seen vegetable-hating monsters gobble down olive-eyed ghosts without a second thought. Parenting win!
• Party perfection – Ghost Pizza Bagels are the ultimate crowd-pleaser – easy to make in big batches, simple to eat while mingling, and guaranteed to get compliments. Last year my neighbor begged for the recipe before she’d even finished her first ghost!

Honestly? The biggest reason I love these is the pure joy they bring. There’s nothing like watching someone’s face light up when they see a platter of cheesy, smiling ghosts coming their way. And when the kids start naming their favorite ghosts before eating them? That’s when you know you’ve created something special in the kitchen.

For more fun recipes and inspiration, be sure to check out our Pinterest page!

Print